About the Post

Author Information

Formerly a PC-exclusive gamer, Kae was introduced to the tabletop world by gateway of the World of Warcraft TCG. Since then, her interests have broadened with her favorite games including Battlestar Galactica, Pathfinder, Lord of the Rings LCG, WarmaHordes, and more. Kae is willing to try just about any game and loves learning new strategy.

The Weight Of A Review

variety dice

You’ve heard of a game that you’re interested in, but you want some insight on how to play the game and how others like it before purchasing. You have many resources to get information from, but a frequently used source now is online reviews. Written and video reviews are available for almost every game out there. However, something I’ve seen more and more recently that I wanted to call to attention is some of the comments I’ve seen on various reviews, and the weight of a single review.

Mostly, I’m referring to commenters that seem to have made their own final decision on a game (whether positive or negative) based on one review.

Just one.

I think as gamers, we all know that a nat 1 isn't ideal.

I think as gamers, we all know that a nat 1 isn’t ideal.

A review is an opinion, though the rules overview should be mostly unbiased. If the rules are bad, then I respect any reviewer’s right to rip them apart. As a reviewer, I’ve done it myself. But as a consumer, I don’t take one source’s score on a game as the be-all end-all in determining whether I will like a game or not. Besides, they are not me.

As with just about any product or service, I do a lot of looking around before I come to a decision. Some of my process involves knowing my review sources and what they may or may not be already biased towards. However, most people will just type in “(Insert Game Name Here) review” to Google and look in the first few links for a review, and go from there. I think that is a great way to find resources, and to even find a new tabletop source that you may come to love. But should one person’s opinion be the end of the line? No, I don’t think so.

With as many reviewers as there are out there, a well informed decision can be made by cross-referencing.

With as many reviewers as there are out there, a well informed decision can be made by cross-referencing.

I say this for many reasons. One is that its pretty easy to tell if someone hasn’t actually played the game, or worse, hasn’t fully read the rules. Those that have read the rules will notice this quickly as the review may be majorly off, especially if they’ve already experienced the game. But if you haven’t played the game, how are you to know? This is where I believe it is incredibly important to cross-reference reviews.

Every reviewer will have different opinions and scores.

Every reviewer will have different opinions and scores. And it is worth finding out why!

This isn’t to say that all reviewers have to be perfect with every detail. We have overlooked a rule before, and have updated our reviews accordingly. Oftentimes, one rule mistake can completely throw a game off track, and I’m sure that almost every reviewer has done this at one point or another. The way you figure that out is by doing your research.

While we stick to our opinions of games (with corrections if we’ve overlooked something), we hope that gamers don’t take any one review as the deciding factor in whether a game is right for them or not. Check out other points of view. See if your local board game group or store has a copy that you can play for yourself. Research the rules if they are available online. Not every game is right for every gamer, but just because one reviewer doesn’t like it, doesn’t mean you won’t!

Tags: , , , , , , ,

One Comment on “The Weight Of A Review”

  1. Joe Pilkus April 13, 2015 at 8:28 PM #

    It’s absolutely a matter of trust…for instance, reading a review (or several reviews) from unknown characters is highly suspect…whereas, I enjoy and generally trust the reviews by both Undead Viking and Radho…why? because they’ve been doing for a number of years; they actually play the game; and while I don’t purchase every game reviewed (in fact, I purchase only 2-3 games per year due to an exceptionally high bar which I set for games), I do trust these gentlemen to provide an excellent overview of the game and their own opinion and thoughts on the game.


Have something to share? Please comment below!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,205 other followers

%d bloggers like this: